Revised Laws of Saint Lucia (2021)

752.   Inadmissible grounds of appeal

No appeal shall be allowed on any of the following grounds—

  1.  

    (a)     that the district court had no jurisdiction in the case unless an objection to the jurisdiction of the district court had been formally taken at any time during the proceedings of the case and before the decision of the Court had been given but if such objection had been so taken, and was well founded, the Court may refer the case back to the magistrate with such directions as it considers proper, or may hear and determine the case upon the merits, and may confirm, reverse or vary the decision of the magistrate or may make such other order in the matter as the Court thinks just, and may by such order exercise any power which the magistrate against whose decision the appeal is made might have exercised;

  1.  

    (b)     that inadmissible evidence has been admitted by the district court, if there is sufficient admissible evidence to sustain the decision;

  1.  

    (c)     that admissible evidence has been rejected; but if the Court considers the objection well founded, it shall proceed in accordance with the provisions of section 751;

  1.  

    (d)     that the case should not have been dealt with as a summary offence;

  1.  

    (e)     that the sentence, penalty or punishment is inadequate;

  1.  

    (f)     that any question of value, compensation or costs has been wrongly determined by the magistrate, unless in the opinion of the Court his or her determination is not altogether supported by the evidence nor justified in the circumstances.